Get a Quote Instantly

Compare your unique insurance quotes online via our comparative quoting form.

Featured Our History

Our History

Our History

Cafegency is truly one of a kind. Eleven years ago we debuted the local independent insurance agency of the future. Cafegency is designed to thrive in the internet age when, ironically, the most unique thing you can offer your customer is good 'ol fashioned face to face personalized service. Sure, we have all of the technology bells and whistles (modern website, 24/7 phone service, online self service options, etc.) but what makes us so special is that we are still HERE for you right in your neighborhood. We are accountable to you, work only for you and get to know you and your unique insurance needs. And we even have an awesome cafe that specializes in delicious coffee drinks and healthful smoothies that gives significant discounted pricing to our active insurance policyholders.

Our Services

Our Partners

  • AAA
  • Allstate
  • Auto Owners
  • Dairyland
  • National General
  • Nationwide
  • Progressive
  • Safeco
  • Travelers